Cable
Innovation and Size Distinguish a Trio of Cable-Stayed Giants
12/5/2005
...Stonecutters Bridge. Some 7,000 tonnes
of parallel wire strand in 224 cables will support that bridges
main span and both sets of four backspans, each stretching
for 289 m.
Locked coil cables were not available
in needed sizes so Stonecutters designers turned to
parallel strand, says Arups Hussain. But because the
enclosing ducts are bigger, allowing insertion of individual
strands, high stresses were predicted in back stays in buffeting
wind. "We had to reduce the wind loading and the only
way was to reduce the diameter of the stay cable," he
says. And that meant specifying slimmer parallel wire cables.
A
Statement. Hong Kongs Stonecutters Bridge
had an international design competition for looks. (Photo
by Peter Reina for ENR)
High Wire
"Ive done quite a lot of parallel-strand stay-cable
installation, but this will be my first project with parallel
wire," says Brian West, project manager with Stonecutters
main contractor. The Maeda-Hitachi-Yokogawa-Hsin Chong Joint
Venture formally signed its $350-million construction contract
in May last year. Having to fabricate entire cables to size
and lift each unit in one piece will be challenging, especially
for the longer cables, says West.
With the bridge visible from Hong
Kong and West Kowloon, the regions Highways Dept. wanted
something special. So it launched an international design
competition, awarding the prize in 2000 to a team led by U.K.-based
Halcrow Group Ltd. However, the design contract was bid separately,
going to Arup with Denmarks Cowi A.S.
Stonecutters 53.5-m-wide
deck will comprise two parallel steel boxes with a 14.3-m
air gap in between. Cross girders set at 18-m intervals link
the 3.9-m-deep steel boxes. Backspans, according to the competition
design, were to be monolithic with the towers for reduced
maintenance. But later analysis revealed high structural torsions
would arise during typhoons, says Hussain. So Arup extended
the steel deck some 50 m into the 78-m-long backspans at both
towers, separating it from the towers, except at horizontal
buffer bearings. To transmit bending moments, the steel and
concrete deck will be post-tensioned together.
WEST
HUSSAIN
SHAM
From the 298-m-tall single-leg
towers, two planes of cables will fan to the anchorages on
the decks edges every 18 m. For aesthetics, only the
lower 60% of the circular towers was originally to be in concrete,
turning into a steel tube for the rest. But that design was
too flexible, causing excessive vibrations in stays, says
Hussain.
To stiffen the tower, Arup extended
the concrete full height, but kept the steel enclosure, acting
compositely. And to ease maintenance, it specified 2-cm-thick
stainless steel weighing over 1,800 tonnes.
Jump casting equipment is now being
prepared to start the first tower and the contractor is procuring
some of the nearly 35,000 tonnes of steelwork in a difficult
market. Not only have steel prices roughly doubled since the
contract was bid but West says sections of the required grade
and thickness, up to 10 cm, are scarce.
As producers focus on more profitable
items, "there have been times when we received rejections
from the mills for certain grades and sizes," West says.
"Some of our partners in the joint venture are very large
steel consumers and we have been able to make some procurements
by utilizing their buying leverage."
The contractor and locally based
Maunsell Consultant Asia Ltd. are designing the construction
process. "With a bridge of this scale, there is extensive
engineering input in the construction," says Robin Sham,
Maunsells transportation executive director.
Wind tunnel tests in China and
the U.K. are being used to investigate responses of the freestanding
tower, the growing deck cantilevers and cable stays in various
construction stages, says Sham. If necessary, the contractors
will develop "precautionary measures," such as temporary
tuned-mass dampers in the deck to mitigate vibrations, he
adds.
Maunsell now is forecasting bridge
geometry at every erection stage to produce setting out data.
"Verification of the effects of the erection scheme on
the permanent structure is naturally a principal activity,"
says Sham. As erection advances, measured data will be used
to refine forecasts. "It takes very tight monitoring
and control," he adds.
Since starting construction early
last year, the contractor this September completed the vast,
13,000-cu-m east pile cap. Partly because of the need to design
around a deep fault under the west tower, foundation work
there lags by about six months. The bridge is founded on piles
up to 2.8 m dia reaching down 75 m deep on the east side and
110 m on the other.
The site also is gearing up to
cast the four backspins on either side, some 60 m above ground
on temporary steel-braced precast concrete towers. Designed
by Maunsell, the tower system is being built with 2x2-m boxes,
match cast in China. They are stacked over 30 boxes high and
stressed together vertically across dry joints for easy removal.
Deck steelwork is due to start
going up at the towers next autumn. Working with VSL Hong
Kong, the joint venture has developed a system of cable-stayed
girders cantilevering from tower sides to raise the first
sections of deck box.
Strand jacks will raise nearly
60-m-lengths of box individual girders simultaneously on either
side of each tower. The boxes will be slid toward each other
to be linked with girders. And they will be slid back to be
stitched to awaiting concrete backspans. The first main span
lift is due in early 2007. Steel will be fabricated into panels
near Beijing by China Railway Shanhaiguan Bridge Group Co.
Ltd. It then will travel to Guangdong for assembly into 18-m
lengths of twin boxes weighing 300 to 500 tonnes each. These
will be raised by gantries from the deck and welded into place.
Working on a nine-day cycle, deck
erection is due to end in summer 2008, adding 128 m the current
record cable-stayed span, Japans Tatara Bridge. But
Stonecutters will never hold the record if the Sutong Bridge
over Chinas Yangtze River meets its 2007 completion
target.
Bold
Move. Chinas Sutong Bridge may be headed
for the record books for size in 2007. (Photos courtesy
of Maunsell Consultants Asia Ltd.)
New Contender
With a 1,088-m cable-stayed main span, the bridge will form
the main section of a 6 km river crossing about 100 km from
Shanghai. Its A-shaped pylons will rise just over 306-m above
the pile caps to support a single 35-m wide steel box girder
deck with a maximum 4-m depth. Construction began in June
2003, with piling completed last year.
The bridge is designed by a consortium
of China Highway Planning and Design Institute, Jiangsu Provincial
Communication Planning and Design Institute and Architectural
Design and Research Institute of Tongji University. Denmark's
COWI is doing checking for the owner, Jiangsu Sutong Bridge
Construction Commanding Dept., and is helping with construction
management.
Prime contractor CHEC Second
Navigation Engineering Bureau, Wuhan, has ordered eight gantries
from U.K.-based Dorman Long Technology Ltd. to raise the 16-m-long
deck sections, each weighing up to 450 tonnes, starting next
August. Like Stonecutters Bridge, the Sutong crossing will
have parallel wire cable, which is commonly used in China,
notes Sham, whose team also is advising the Chinese prime
contractor.
Gives readers a glimpse of who is planning and constructing some of the largest projects throughout the U.S. Much information for pulse is derived from McGraw-Hill Construction Dodge.
For more information on a project in Pulse that has a DR#, or for general information on Dodge products and services, please visit our Website at www.dodge.construction.com.
Information is provided on construction projects in following stages in each issue of ENR: Planning, Contracts/Bids/Proposals and Bid/Proposal Dates.